Nov 01, 2016 your students can improve their work by recognizing the strengths and weaknesses in the work of others. Editing marks should also be used during peer editing. The research finding is that the students taught by using peer editing technique reached higher improvement than those students taught by using selfediting technique. Peer editing is a step in the writing process that helps students evaluate and improve the quality of their written work in.
The how and why of peer editing in the esl writing class. The result of this research indicated that peer editing improve student writing skill from cycle to cyle. As a peer editor, your job is to be as specific as possible in helping your classmates write a clear and strong paper. Enhanced encouraging peer editing columbia university. Peer and self editing strategies are social and metacognitive strategies used in the steps of sharing, revising, and editing in writing. Peer editing sheet by mrwatts teachers pay teachers. It is better for the lecturer implemented the peer editing technique as the alternative ways to improve students writing skill. After going through the piece as a whole, you need to check it word by word, line by line. She used peerediting as her technique in teaching writing. Ideally, start by pointing out the papers strengths, and then move on to identify points that.
Marilyn erano, another eighth grade teacher, incorporated the writing rubric into a peer editing technique she had been using for years. Compliment the author what are a few things that you liked about the authors writing. Make specific suggestions regarding the authors word choice use of details organization sentence length topic 3. Choose a student who has demonstrated a strong grasp of the editing process and grammatical concepts. Jan 25, 2017 use a fishbowl technique to allow the class to observe a peer editing session between two of their classmates. The way to complete the online peer editing form on the internet. Enter your official identification and contact details. The main problem discussed in this study was to determine if the use of peerediting technique is effective in teaching writing to the eight grade of junior high school and the objective was to know the students achievement during teaching learning process by using this technique. The study contributes to teaching pedagogy by encouraging teachers to use peerediting in the writing classroom and to focus on the correction of few language errors. When editing for content, you are making sure the essay flows in a way that makes sense and is consistent with the overall theme and thesis of the piece. Peer editing sheet summer reading essay name of peer editor. The objective of this research was to explain whether using peer editing technique can improve students writing skill at the eight grade of smp n 3 kota bengkulu.
Peer editing research paper checklist author check peer check description points 20 title page header visible with students last name, space and page number. Neatly highlight the editing marks you make so your classmate can find them. Peer editing is a technique often used in composition and other writingintensive courses. Editing checklist for self and peer editing readwritethink. Be kind when you point out mistakes to your partner. Choose a student who has demonstrated a strong grasp of.
The peer editing sheet is organized for three rounds of peer editing, though it can be used for just a few rounds as well. So this kind of structured peerediting model alleviates some of these issues, and gives students some tools to work with to really help their peers. Take turns editing and try to give honest feedback to your partner. Below are ten areas that you can consider to help provide constructive feedback to other students. The following are commonly used editing marks when proofreading writing. In fact, we learn best when we work together maximizing your peers learning as well as your own. Handout there are three steps to good peer editing. Pdf the objective of the research was to know the description of how critical thinking skill can be optimized in teaching writing using peer editing. Working in pairs or groups of three, students switched papers and edited each others work. Assessmentdriven improvements in middle school students.
Now that you all had a chance to see what peer editing looks like, its your turn to try. This peer editing sheet was created in order to give students a structured and organized way to critically analyze their classroom peers writing efforts. Peer response and editing are processes through which students respond to and provide feedback on their peers writing. Does the writer include the authors name and title of the book somewhere in the intro. Peer editing handout wesl university prep spring 2014. Most people think that this is the only part of editing you need to do, but thats totally wrong. The use of these tips also has the benefit of allowing students to gain valuable. It does take a commitment from the reader to look closely at anothers writing and to make appropriate comments for improvement. Learning by teaching you have probably experienced firsthand or heard that the best way to learn something. Many programs feature older, more experienced peers, or those. Its totally possible to offer helpful feedback without sending both you. Peer editing is a step in the writing process that helps.
Does heshe focus on just one vignette from a summer life or the house on mango street. Make specific suggestions regarding the authors word choice use of details organization sentence. This shows that the peer editing technique influenced students essay writing. Organization introduction introduction begins with an attention grabber or hook. It is helpful to select a student who has a good understanding of the criteria on the rubric, such as proper grammar and punctuation. Underlining and changes are permitted if done in pencil. Oct 02, 2015 peer editing technique for teaching writing 1.
I also use this resource as an assessment tool when marking their final pub. Use these marks during part of the revision stage in the writing process, and for the editing stage as well. Assessmentdriven improvements in middle school students writing. Staple a blank editing sheet to the top of the first essay you receive. Peerediting instructions make sure that everyone in the group has a different colored writing utensil. Sep 15, 2018 at process street, we make it a rule that no paragraph can be over two sentences in length. Effects of peer versus selfediting on students revision of. Writing skill, peer editng technique, iain pontianak. Peer editing involves students working together to evaluate and revise each others writing. Peer editing form fill out and sign printable pdf template. Use a fishbowl technique to allow the class to observe a peerediting session between two of their classmates. The center for writing and speaking mccain library 404. Ask a classmate to read through what you have written, check. Two rivers public charter school grades pk 8 washington, dc explore more resources from.
Edit the entire essay using a red pen to edit spelling, capitalization, and punctuation. Editing a classmates work, however, can be a little stressful for writer and editor alike, but dont fret the next time you are asked to be a peer editor. They are not meant to take the place of teacher evaluation, but when incorporated into the writing process, they can be useful learning tools for both the writer and the student providing feedback. Editing marks should also be used during peerediting. Students first and last name upper left hand corner. This is a peer editing checklist i use with my intermediate classes in order to assessimprove fictional narrative writing pieces. Peer teaching is a suite of practices in which peers instruct each other in a purposedriven, meaningful interaction. Write the authors name where it belongs on the editing sheet. At process street, we make it a rule that no paragraph can be over two sentences in length. Peer editing in the following document, which relates to chapter 21 of acting on words, we comment briefly on the general principles of peer editing, illustrate those principles, and then discuss online peer editing boards. Fifth grade lesson in writing peer editing betterlesson.
The advanced tools of the editor will lead you through the editable pdf template. Writing is a process of exploring ideas to share the writersa ideas with the readers through written language. One of the difficulties faced by students when they wr. Using peer editing technique to improve students writing skill at grade viii1 of smp n 3 kota bengkulu this study was a classroom action research. They use the coach process in addition to the rubric. Ask a classmate to read through what you have written. Introduction writing is a system for interpersonal communication using various styles of language jalaludin, 2011. Passive voice allows a writer to create a sentence with a verb and an object but no subject, and it can be confusing for the reader. Use a fishbowl technique to allow the class to view a self and peer edit session of two of their classmates. Students engaged in peer editing trade drafts of material they have written and provide each other with suggestions for improvement. Here are five specific, handson approaches to peer conferencing that your students can really sink their teeth into. The effectiveness, peer and selfediting technique, writing skill introduction. Models of and research into the writing process support the use of peer editing in the regular activities of a writing class.
Since both groups received teacher instruction in editing language errors, but only the experimental group engaged in peerediting, these results may be attributed to peerediting. Likewise, peer editing is an essential part of the process for student writers who want to improve and succeed. This study aimed to find out whether or not there was a significant difference in recount writing achievement of the tenth grade students of sma negeri 3 prabumulih between those who were taught through peer editing technique and those who were not and to find out whether or not there was a significant difference in recount writing achievement after the students were taught through. The objective of the study is to see how peer and self. Body there are at least three body paragraphs each indented. Through peer editing technique, the students were able to generate and organized their ideas and produce a text as well. Peer editing in this partstage of the writing process we help others to improve their writing, which helps us become better writers as well. To do this, first choose one student to model the self editing phase. Ask a classmate to read through what you have written, check off the box next to each question, and write a brief comment that will help improve your work. Peer editing for teaching writing ana fauziah a1b011 2. Peer teaching in the efl classroom in japan kim bradfordwatts kyoto womens university what is peer teaching. So this kind of structured peer editing model alleviates some of these issues, and gives students some tools to work with to really help their peers. Writing is one of the important skill topics taught to junior high school students. The effectiveness, peer and self editing technique, writing skill introduction.
Peerediting dictionary definition peerediting defined. Peer editing is a vital element of writing classes, and by using the techniques mentioned above, students grow to become better writers, and the methods help to create a collaborative atmosphere in the classroom. With your partner you may return to your seats with a checklist. The research finding is that the students taught by using peer editing technique reached higher improvement than those students taught by using self editing technique. Peer editing handout in our classroom, each student is appreciated, entitled to their opinion, and viewed as a valuable source of knowledge. Peer editing technique, writing, teaching english writing. Additionally, they can learn about their own writing, since part of the reason to do peer editing is for students to learn from each other as they read each others work and to give students an. Peer editing inclass peer editing exchange papers with someone in your row. Oct 27, 2016 likewise, peer editing is an essential part of the process for student writers who want to improve and succeed. If it doesnt draw you in, make some suggestions for.
This research is an experiment which compares the peer and selfediting. Eleventh grade lesson peer editing the synthesis essay. Your students can improve their work by recognizing the strengths and weaknesses in the work of others. Do not simply answer yes to all of the following questions. Feel free to edit this to fit the needs of your classroom. In either case, its useful to know what works best.
306 465 1223 252 303 993 1174 32 270 99 1627 56 280 1299 1195 1142 848 752 1434 521 477 709 1507 163 1354 595 1121 12 1173 119 358 6 1521 202 961 46 177 358 1137 589 510 4